01:15.7
We have to send some group of policemen, maybe NBI from Manila.
01:22.7
Because, you know, those policemen in Davao City.
01:25.7
Might not be able to find him or may not want to find. I mean, is it really that bad yung so-called Davao Task Force?
01:38.6
I mean, ako kasi, I mean, for me, ang point of reference ko, Justice, is si Bantag. Di ba? He's from my region, Cordilleras, ganun.
01:45.7
Hanggang ngayon, parang hindi natin nauuli eh, di ba? So, I don't know, unless siguro nag-golf course ka sa East Timor, mukhang malabo mauhuli ka unless magpadala ka from Manila.
01:55.7
So, bakit totoo yan, no, Justice? Talagang medyo mahirap umasa minsan, no?
01:59.7
Kaya, like, Bantag na lang, no? Ang tagal na.
02:02.7
Ang tagal na yung Bantag na yan eh. I mean, of course, I mean, this is crazy. Obviously, for all we know, may kinalaman talaga ito dun sa first major, you know, EJK or murder of four journalists.
02:15.0
And, sabi ko, kung si Bantag nga, hanggang ngayon, hindi nila mahanap-hanap, you wonder what the heck is going on and then whether dito sa Kibuloy meron tayong update.
02:22.3
Kaya, tinanong kita kasi Davao, from Davao kayo, sir.
02:25.7
Scorpio. So, baka naman, sabi ko, baka may insider knowledge kayo na pwede forward sa amin.
02:30.3
Justice Scorpio, of course, we need to talk about Digong, our favorite president soon.
02:34.7
But before going there, what is your understanding ng itong latest na development sa Scarborough Shoal, sa Panatak Shoal naman ito, di ba?
02:42.1
Hindi naman ito sa Ayungin Shoal, so sa kabila naman ito. What's going on right now in the West Philippine Sea?
02:55.7
China. Because they're anticipating we will go to Red Bank to survey and drill together with the Joint Patrol with the U.S.
03:03.6
And this is part of their pressure to warn us that there will be the same treatment when we go to Red Bank.
03:14.7
But really, I don't think they will do it because they were not able to do it to Malaysia and to Indonesia.
03:21.3
So, ibang kwasyon. Because that's the open sea.
03:25.5
It's not a high tide feature. It's totally submerged.
03:31.9
So, that's a different category.
03:35.5
But they will nevertheless try to intimidate us not to go to Red Bank.
03:40.1
Right. So, we're looking at developments in Red Bank, Ayungin Shoal, of course, previously, and also in Scarborough Shoal.
03:46.6
So, let's talk about Red Bank and Scarborough Shoal more.
03:49.4
Kasi last time, puro mga Ayungin Shoal tayo, which is, of course, important.
03:52.1
Pero balikan natin, what should be the strategy in the Red Bank?
03:55.5
Before we go to the Scarborough Shoal, Justice Carpio.
03:58.8
Well, in the Red Bank, we have to start our survey and reeling because that's a requirement to get the gas.
04:07.6
And that's how Malaysia and Indonesia started it.
04:12.7
And unless we go there to survey and reel, we cannot get the gas.
04:17.3
So, the first step is to survey and reel so that they know that they just need confirmatory.
04:24.5
So, we can start getting.
04:28.2
It takes four years to develop a Red Bank because you have to put up the platform, put up the pipeline from Red Bank to Malampaya.
04:37.7
So, we really have to start.
04:40.0
We're already delayed, very much delayed.
04:44.5
Justice, I want to go back to this.
04:46.1
Kasi dun sa mga, itago na natin sa pangalan ng mga makapili.
04:50.1
Ang parating argument nila, bakit tayo hindi katulad ng mga ibang ASEAN?
04:54.5
Napakabaitan sa China.
04:55.2
Ngayon, kumukuha sila ng investments.
04:57.4
Well, one of the things that they don't talk about is how Vietnam, Malaysia, Indonesia, all of them pushed ahead with various degrees of success dito sa kanilang energy exploration activities.
05:06.9
Pwede natin isa-isayin ng mga yan.
05:08.4
I mean, of course, it's just an overview without giving too much details.
05:11.7
Para lang maintindihan ng ating mga kababayan na actually lumalaban itong mga kapitbahay natin.
05:17.1
Tayo yung medyo kulelat ngayon.
05:18.6
Hindi yung tayo lang yung lumalaban at sila yung mabait sa China.
05:22.0
So, let's start, for instance, with...
05:25.1
Because I think Malaysia is the most notorious now because of Anwar Ibrahim doing his own Duterte lawyering for China for the lack of better way of putting it.
05:32.9
And then, let's go to Indonesia.
05:34.1
Then, of course, Vietnam, which is the biggest one in terms of development of offshore drilling platforms.
05:41.6
During the COVID, about two years ago, Malaysia announced that the Malaysian economy is dependent on oil and gas exports.
05:53.7
That's what's fueling...
05:54.5
That's what's fueling their economic development.
05:55.9
And their reserves of gas, oil and gas, have gone down almost.
06:03.0
They need to open up new wells.
06:05.4
So, they announced that they will survey and drill in their area within their exclusive economic zone but falling within the 10-dash line.
06:15.7
So, China said, you cannot do that.
06:17.9
We will stop you.
06:20.3
Threatening to go to war even, no?
06:22.1
But Malaysia still said...
06:24.5
It's a survey and drill ship together with its navy.
06:28.1
At the same time, the Australian and the American warships conducted naval drills in the same area.
06:34.8
So, the Chinese Coast Guard could not do anything.
06:37.8
And the Malaysians were able to complete their survey and drilling.
06:42.1
And the same thing happened to Indonesia.
06:45.0
Indonesia announced that it needed to survey and drill in the Natunas facing the South China Sea.
06:52.9
That's also enclosed.
06:54.5
By the 10-dash line.
06:55.5
China said, that's our area.
06:59.3
You cannot get the gas there.
07:01.3
But Indonesia still proceeded.
07:03.5
Accompanied by its navy, the Indians sent its survey and drill ship.
07:07.8
And at the same time, the U.S. aircraft carrier, Ronald Reagan, passed by.
07:12.4
So, the Chinese Coast Guard couldn't do anything.
07:15.4
So, they finished their survey and drilling.
07:17.9
And we are the only country among the three countries that have not surveyed and drilled.
07:24.5
Well, because during the time of Duterte, he didn't want to displease President Xi Jinping.
07:29.4
He said there will be a massacre.
07:32.1
We cannot fight China.
07:34.4
So, right now, Malampay used to supply three of our largest gas-fired plants.
07:41.3
Today, it's supplying only two.
07:44.3
And next year, by the end of this year, it will be supplying only one because the gas pressure has been going down.
07:51.6
And probably in 2026,
07:54.5
we'll run out of gas already.
07:57.0
They expect Malampay to run out of gas by 2027.
08:02.1
Of course, the company of Ricky Razon has promised to drill three new wells in the Malampay area.
08:14.4
I mean, you can't be sure.
08:15.8
You cannot place all our eggs in one basket.
08:19.9
We have really to develop Malampay as a replacement.
08:24.5
I mean, the lemon has been squeezed.
08:27.6
I mean, like, you can't just squeeze it so much, right?
08:31.5
Now, this is very important, Justice Carpio, because, again, I think there's a misunderstanding na yung mga kapit-bahay natin
08:36.9
ay nagsusubmit lang sa China and they're just allowing China to get its way.
08:40.1
But the reality is that they speak softly most of the time, but they do their assignment.
08:44.0
And once in a while, they speak out.
08:45.9
We see the trend line with both Indonesia and Malaysia.
08:48.5
And, of course, Vietnam is a totally different story.
08:50.9
Ang napansin ko nga, Justice Carpio, particularly Indonesia and Vietnam,
08:54.5
also bring in India and Russia, right?
08:57.1
Dun sa mga energy projects nila.
08:58.7
Especially Russia is interesting because Russia is supposed to be a friend of China,
09:02.6
but Russian companies, whether it's Gazprom, among others,
09:05.3
have been helping some of China's rivals to develop their offshore capacity, offshore resources, right?
09:12.4
Yes, because Vietnam is very clever.
09:19.3
It got also Exxon from the U.S.
09:22.3
So, it knows that...
09:24.3
China will put pressure, will try to stop if they do it on their own.
09:31.6
So, what Vietnam did was to partner with the two nuclear-armed states, U.S. and Russia.
09:40.4
And India too, ONGC, if I'm not mistaken, right?
09:44.5
So, they brought in three nuclear powers to develop there.
09:47.5
So, I mean, that's smart, right?
09:49.5
You make them invested.
09:50.6
And we saw, I think, China was quite successful.
09:54.2
They were intimidating the Spanish, I think, Repsol, right?
10:00.6
The Spanish gave up.
10:01.9
But the other ones seem to be hanging around, right?
10:04.4
The Russians, the Indians, among others.
10:06.4
They're still there.
10:07.2
They denied that they have stopped.
10:10.3
But Repsol really left.
10:12.2
The Vietnamese government compensated Repsol for all their expenses.
10:16.8
But the Russians, the Americans are still there.
10:19.3
They're just quiet as of the moment.
10:22.3
So, maybe that should be...
10:24.2
the blueprint for us, right?
10:26.7
Now, Justice Carpenter, of course, I remember the other year,
10:30.0
there was an incident where China was trying to harass
10:32.3
the Joint Jakarta-Indonesia-Russian oil drilling project.
10:40.5
Indonesia made some noise about it.
10:42.2
I think they did also some patrols in the area.
10:44.2
It looks like, you know, by fits and pieces,
10:47.4
they keep on moving forward.
10:48.9
Do you think this is also the way for us in the rig bank?
10:51.7
Because we haven't developed this rig bank for a long time.
10:54.2
Justice Carpenter, you know, I mean,
10:55.4
do you think it's time for us to just elbow our way in
10:58.2
and patrol in the area and make sure China doesn't stop us?
11:02.4
Well, we should follow the formula adapted by Malaysia and Indonesia.
11:09.2
They sent their server ship accompanied by their navy.
11:12.1
But on the side, the Americans were there in the same area.
11:16.0
Now, the Americans have offered to conduct joint patrols.
11:19.2
So, I think when the joint patrols with the U.S. happens,
11:22.9
that's the time we will be sending our server ship to rig bank.
11:29.3
And I think it's going to happen soon.
11:31.2
Right. So, the moment of truth is arriving now.
11:33.9
Ang dahilan na sinasabi natin ito,
11:35.4
dahil ngayon napaka-init at nakikita natin,
11:37.7
minsan, ba't yung mga malls, di ba,
11:39.4
nasa-shutdown na yung kanilang electricity.
11:41.2
I think you can feel the power crisis.
11:44.0
Even in the more privileged areas of Manila,
11:46.1
admittedly, di ba, nakikita ko minsan,
11:47.7
ba't yung mga malls nasa-shutdown na talagang,
11:51.0
ano tayo, hirap na hirap tayo.
11:52.6
In terms of power capacity.
11:54.1
So, this is not only about sustaining our 6%, 7% growth.
11:58.1
This is about just sustaining our basic needs.
12:00.4
So, malala itong energy crisis natin,
12:02.6
looming energy crisis natin.
12:04.8
Yeah. It's very, it will really derail us.
12:09.2
Because if you remove Malampaya,
12:11.8
we'll have 30-40 hours of daily burnout in Luzon.
12:15.3
And that will devastate the economy.
12:17.4
That means that the factories will have to close.
12:20.2
And those who want to locate,
12:22.7
in the Philippines,
12:23.4
will not locate in the Philippines.
12:24.7
Those who are here already,
12:26.3
will have to leave.
12:27.4
They'll transfer to Vietnam.
12:28.6
Because the moment we import LNG
12:31.6
to replace our Malampaya gas,
12:34.6
that means power rates will go up.
12:36.5
And they will not be competitive anymore.
12:38.5
If you are here in the Philippines
12:40.5
to establish a manufacturing platform for export,
12:43.7
you're competing with the exporters
12:45.5
from Vietnam and China
12:47.4
where power rates are much, much lower.
12:51.7
They're actually,
12:52.6
we're not imposing taxes on their power plants.
12:57.8
We're imposing maybe 200% taxes
13:02.1
on our energy sector.
13:06.4
So, they will all leave.
13:08.8
Because they cannot compete.
13:10.9
I mean, the power cost in manufacturing
13:15.6
ranges from 20% to 60% of your total cost.
13:18.3
It's just not possible for them to compete.
13:20.8
Yeah, it's just too much.
13:21.6
Especially for...
13:22.3
That means our drive now
13:25.7
is to get more FDI,
13:27.2
foreign direct investments.
13:28.9
When the power outages happen,
13:31.9
they will all leave.
13:33.6
And of course, Justice Corbett,
13:35.1
it is good for the Philippines
13:36.5
to have power crisis
13:37.7
for certain countries, right?
13:40.1
Because if we have a power crisis,
13:41.6
we have instability.
13:42.6
If we have instability,
13:43.8
the popularity of the government will go down.
13:45.7
And we know who will benefit
13:47.3
if the popularity of Marcos goes down.
13:50.0
Heartbeat away is one.
13:51.4
I mean, let's be honest.
13:52.3
I think, you know,
13:53.6
some people like status quo
13:55.2
because status quo means disaster
13:56.7
for the Philippines, for Marcos.
13:58.8
And therefore, it's a good news
13:60.0
dun sa mga kabila, diba?
14:01.1
Mga makapili, mga pro-China.
14:03.6
ito na kaya kasi inaway nyo kasing China,
14:07.2
let's surrender to them
14:08.0
and everything will be fine, right?
14:09.1
I mean, that's where we're going, right?
14:10.8
If we don't do anything drastic in Reitbank.
14:14.6
if we cannot get the gas in Reitbank,
14:19.3
the economy will be devastated
14:22.3
President Bombo Marcos
14:23.9
will become very unpopular.
14:27.3
That will happen.
14:29.2
And potentially even overthrowing or something.
14:32.2
I mean, this is crazy.
14:35.0
Now, Justice Garbis,
14:36.3
so what you're saying is that
14:37.8
soon we might find out
14:39.7
some drastic moves by us
14:41.8
to unilaterally develop
14:44.6
legitimately ours.
14:45.5
Unilaterally in the sense that
14:46.8
wala na yung mga joint exploration,
14:49.0
joint development,
14:49.7
yung mga ganon hanash na digong, diba?
14:52.3
Mukhang wala na yun.
14:53.1
Deads na yun, diba?
14:54.0
Yung mga ganyan yung discussion.
14:56.3
Yeah, because they,
14:57.9
we signed an MOU with them,
14:60.0
during the later part of the
15:02.2
Duterte administration.
15:03.8
And we agreed, okay,
15:05.2
we will jointly cooperate.
15:08.4
But at the last minute,
15:09.6
they said they wanted two things removed
15:12.0
from our service contract.
15:13.4
That because the service contract says
15:15.6
whereas the oil and gas
15:16.8
belong to the Philippines.
15:18.8
They wanted that removed.
15:22.3
the second provision
15:22.7
they wanted removed
15:23.5
was that the service contract says
15:26.3
the contract should be governed
15:28.7
by Philippine law.
15:29.8
They wanted that removed.
15:32.0
they want us to violate
15:33.9
and they want to reverse
15:35.2
the arbitral award.
15:38.5
we could not allow that.
15:39.3
Big no yan, big no yan.
15:42.5
So, you're cautiously optimistic
15:44.3
that we may soon move
15:46.4
because we're just desperate.
15:47.7
I mean, we lost all of those years,
15:49.5
I mean, justice, right?
15:51.9
it's long overdue.
15:54.8
it takes four years.
15:56.1
And we are now almost
15:57.4
in the second year
15:59.2
of the Marcos administration.
16:03.0
And if there is still no
16:05.1
light at the end of the tunnel
16:06.6
when we have our 2028 elections,
16:09.4
then whoever is the candidate
16:11.7
supported by President Bibiam
16:13.7
will have a hard time.
16:15.9
He cannot anoint his successor.
16:18.9
So, my long term,
16:19.6
again, this will help the other side, right?
16:21.9
for China's side, right?
16:23.1
Their narrative na,
16:24.2
yan kasi inawain yung China
16:25.4
kung saan na nag,
16:27.3
ano, ni Digong co-ownership, right?
16:29.6
ewan ko yung conjugal understanding niya.
16:31.8
kay Digong niyan.
16:33.3
So, that's why it's very important.
16:36.3
even if we start this year,
16:38.0
because we lost all those years
16:39.9
there's gonna be a transitional phase
16:41.5
na medyo masakit, diba?
16:42.9
So, unfortunately,
16:43.9
the damage has been quite done.
16:45.3
It's just a matter of making sure
16:46.4
hindi mag-hemorrhage yan.
16:51.1
because it takes four years
16:52.3
to develop the bank.
16:53.4
So, we will suffer in the meantime.
16:56.1
once they know that we are getting the gas,
16:58.5
people will be happy already.
17:03.1
another issue that can be raised
17:04.3
with Duterte, right?
17:05.1
That he wasted so many years.
17:06.6
He didn't develop the area.
17:08.3
He allowed himself to be,
17:10.1
strung along by China
17:11.5
in these useless negotiations
17:13.4
where, obviously,
17:14.3
China will never agree
17:15.2
to giving up their excessive,
17:17.1
expansive illegal claims.
17:18.5
So, we lost years.
17:19.7
Two years, probably.
17:21.1
So, wala na tayong...
17:22.2
So, in that sense,
17:23.3
I mean, Justice Carpenter,
17:24.4
the reason I keep on asking you about this
17:26.7
parang napansin ko,
17:27.9
konti lang tao may alam dito.
17:29.9
Or hindi masyadong pinag-uusapan ito.
17:32.4
Parang tayo-tayo lang nag-uusap
17:33.8
ukol dito sa re-bank issue na yan.
17:35.9
Do you think may pakakulang ang gobyerno?
17:37.8
Dapat mas i-publicize nila?
17:39.4
Kasi malaking bagay ito.
17:41.9
They're also afraid to alarm.
17:47.3
So, they're trying to control
17:54.2
of importing LNG.
17:56.5
If you have to import LNG,
17:58.3
inflation will shoot up.
18:00.8
Power rates will shoot up.
18:02.6
If we don't import,
18:07.1
of brownout every day.
18:10.2
we know that we will suffer
18:13.6
because it will take
18:14.6
four years to develop RIDWA.
18:16.6
if we can get the gas,
18:18.2
we're starting to develop it.
18:20.0
there's light at the end
18:22.8
And if there is hope,
18:24.0
you can have a bright future.
18:26.8
Hold on to something.
18:29.0
Hold on to something.
18:30.9
there will be relief soon.
18:33.8
if we cannot even start
18:35.8
surveying and drilling,
18:38.7
we're in a dead end.
18:40.7
we have really to import LNG,
18:42.8
which is the only solution.
18:45.3
our power rates will shoot up.
18:47.5
Inflation will go through the roof.
18:51.0
It will be terrible
18:55.0
and for our people.
18:57.6
thank you very much, Joseph.
18:59.1
ang concern ko is
18:60.0
kailangan ba rin natin mag-ingay?
19:02.8
baka gusto ng gobyerno
19:07.1
in terms of optics,
19:09.0
We just do the right thing quietly
19:10.3
like our neighbors.
19:11.0
Don't you think maybe...
19:11.8
Well, I know they're preparing.
19:13.2
I know they're preparing.
19:14.7
Yeah, they're preparing.
19:18.0
the joint patrols
19:19.1
started off the coast of Palawan.
19:21.0
Moving towards the
19:26.0
you just have to assume
19:28.8
if they're moving,
19:34.7
big, big trouble.
19:36.2
they would be so incompetent
19:38.4
if they're not moving now.
19:40.3
Medyo suicidal na politically
19:41.8
and potentially economically, no?
19:44.1
No movies made on that.
19:45.9
maybe there is a logic
19:49.6
not much smoke coming out
19:52.7
looming energy crisis
19:53.8
if hindi ma-develop
19:55.6
Now, Justice Curry,
19:56.3
pag-usapan naman natin
19:58.1
bahaw sa masinlok
20:01.3
I had an interview
20:01.8
with Son Trillanes
20:03.7
and his position is,
20:07.5
I've heard like 12 versions.
20:09.3
But his version is,
20:11.6
dun sa mutual disengagement
20:13.4
should stop the Philippines
20:14.9
from challenging China's
20:17.1
tenuous administrative
20:20.5
China has not reclaimed yet
20:22.1
Scar Barshal, right?
20:23.0
They have no military facilities there.
20:29.1
we can challenge, right?
20:34.4
I'm not even sure
20:35.1
if I can call it occupation.
20:36.7
A tenuous encirclement
20:38.2
of Scar Barshal, right?
20:40.8
I think it's something
20:41.8
we haven't talked about as much.
20:44.4
feel free to share
20:45.5
your point of view.
20:46.2
Parang inisip ko is,
20:47.5
baka naman sa Scar Barshal,
20:48.5
we also have to make
20:49.1
some moves there.
20:50.5
na-reclaim yan eh.
20:52.1
nakatinga lang tayo.
20:53.0
Hindi naman natin
20:57.4
China surrounded Scar Barshal
20:59.9
with their maritime militia
21:05.0
they are in actual control.
21:06.6
But they have not
21:07.8
erected any structure there.
21:11.9
Declaration of Conduct
21:14.4
which prohibits the
21:17.0
of unoccupied features.
21:18.8
You cannot inhabit
21:20.5
uninhabited features
21:24.7
they don't want to break
21:26.0
Code of Conduct yet.
21:29.8
they're not ready
21:34.4
lahat ng mga ibang ginawa nila
21:35.8
because they already
21:37.6
those other features
21:39.3
Declaration of Conduct.
21:41.1
they're kinda like
21:45.2
They're trying to
21:46.3
comply with that.
21:50.5
they're in possession
21:51.5
because they've surrounded it.
21:53.5
That's what they did
21:54.4
also to sand decay.
21:55.6
They've surrounded it,
21:56.8
but they have not built.
21:58.3
And what they're doing
21:59.7
slowly they're adding
22:01.3
they're adding sand
22:14.9
for one reason or another,
22:19.2
Declaration of Conduct.
22:21.0
what we should do
22:25.3
the Arbitral Tribunal again.
22:27.4
Because that's a common
22:29.7
And to have a common
22:31.4
you must have common
22:33.4
And China refuses
22:34.3
to sit down with us.
22:36.6
tribunal and say,
22:37.9
you declared this as a
22:41.2
common fishing rules.
22:43.7
these are our proposal
22:44.7
and we want this to be
22:46.2
approved by the tribunal.
22:51.7
China will not appear
22:52.7
but Vietnam will appear
22:54.1
because Vietnam is also
22:56.0
to that common fishing
23:00.2
we'll have another
23:03.3
And the world will rally
23:04.6
behind that Arbitral Award again
23:06.2
because that's the rule of law.
23:08.7
2016 Arbitral Award.
23:12.3
piling Arbitral Awards.
23:21.0
in the South China Sea
23:25.4
That's his hair, right?
23:27.1
That's his fox style.
23:28.9
We're all together
23:29.9
in the conferences, right?
23:32.4
He's a nice kind person.
23:33.9
He was there in Oxford
23:36.2
together with him.
23:46.2
only the islands.
23:47.6
It was Wu Shigong
23:49.3
we will claim also
23:50.7
beyond the territorial sea.
23:52.5
So, that's why now
23:54.7
the nine-dash line
23:55.8
is their national boundary
23:57.0
and everything enclosed
23:58.5
is their national territory.
24:01.0
for the longest time,
24:03.3
the Arbitral Award
24:05.8
is null and void.
24:11.0
despite everything,
24:13.7
the Arbitral Award
24:18.7
A negative impact
24:20.6
be erased anymore.
24:26.1
create a domino effect.
24:28.3
Other ASEAN countries
24:31.1
the rest of the world
24:31.8
will support us also.
24:36.2
arbitration case.
24:38.6
So, he told them,
24:40.7
to his government,
24:43.8
from filing another case.
24:45.3
Can you just imagine that?
24:47.1
So, what do we do?
24:48.1
We file another case.
24:49.9
Because that will
24:51.5
pile up our awards,
24:53.7
our arbitral awards,
24:54.7
and the rest of the world
24:56.5
because that's the rule of law.
24:58.3
So, we should file
25:02.2
to file a second case
25:03.4
for the destruction
25:05.0
of the marine environment
25:10.2
the common fishing ground rules
25:12.2
in Scarborough Shore.
25:16.2
Plus, we will add
25:17.2
the dangerous maneuvers
25:18.4
when they water cannon
25:23.3
and before vessel.
25:33.2
the second arbitration case.
25:35.3
And they are in dread
25:36.4
of a second arbitration case.
25:40.8
if people like Trillianis
25:42.7
perhaps the way forward
25:43.6
is to challenge them
25:45.3
through naval force,
25:47.5
what you're saying
25:49.5
is the next way forward.
25:50.5
Although, of course,
25:51.0
I don't see necessary
25:51.8
those two mutual exclusives.
25:53.2
We can sequence that, right?
25:54.7
We can file an additional one
25:56.5
and if hindi na naman
25:57.3
na-comply ng China,
25:58.3
then the law is on our side,
25:59.9
then we can challenge it physically.
26:02.3
compliance enforcement capacity
26:05.5
But, if the law is on our side,
26:07.3
then the international community,
26:09.3
will be on our side
26:09.9
if ever we want to enforce it
26:11.3
together with Vietnam
26:12.3
and other countries
26:13.0
who also have shared interests.
26:15.5
kasi parang status ko
26:16.8
is like nakatinga lang,
26:18.3
Like, China is just
26:20.1
Nothing is happening.
26:21.0
I mean, it's just frozen.
26:21.9
It's a frozen conflict.
26:24.1
I've heard a lot of people
26:27.1
an indignity to us.
26:30.3
we are being water-cannoned
26:34.5
So, what are we doing?
26:37.0
that was the case
26:38.0
that was the situation
26:40.4
President Aquino III.
26:42.9
When China seized
26:44.3
Scarborough Shoal
26:47.2
he was the commander-in-chief.
26:48.6
Philippine territory
26:50.9
because that's territory.
26:54.5
you send your navy
26:57.0
the Scarborough Shoal.
27:00.2
we were outnumbered.
27:03.6
by about 20 to 1.
27:05.5
20 Chinese vessels
27:07.0
against one of our vessels.
27:09.0
So, he had to do something.
27:14.9
the arbitration case.
27:16.3
We are in the same situation.
27:18.6
we have to do something.
27:19.7
Because otherwise,
27:20.6
the people will say,
27:22.6
binububog na lang tayo
27:25.1
technical waters.
27:26.8
So, we have to do something.
27:28.1
We have to file a case.
27:33.3
is being hurt now.
27:38.0
it's like we are being slapped
27:39.3
and we just offer
27:43.0
We will file another case.
27:48.6
do exactly what they dread.
27:54.4
both Condor Tariela
27:56.6
over the past 48 hours or so.
28:00.6
we have to be David,
28:02.6
But David was smaller
28:04.3
But hindi siya Kawawa.
28:05.6
he was a warrior,
28:07.5
he had the weapons,
28:09.0
Or, you know what I'm saying?
28:11.0
ang problema dito is,
28:12.1
misa mukha tayong Kawawa,
28:13.5
hindi tayong mukhang
28:14.1
underdog na may laban.
28:16.1
we remind the world na
28:18.6
na may laban tayo dito.
28:19.6
Kasi this is also
28:20.3
psychological warfare,
28:23.1
If you just put it
28:27.4
is a rallying point.
28:30.0
of all the naval powers.
28:34.2
Because of that award,
28:35.0
that's the symbol
28:35.9
of international law.
28:37.1
They want to preserve that.
28:39.3
piling these awards
28:41.3
their support for us.
28:43.1
Because if we go there
28:44.2
to Scarborough Shoal
28:51.4
it's the right thing to do.
28:55.7
the arbitral tribunal,
28:57.2
then they will be
28:58.7
because that follows
29:00.3
international law.
29:04.6
raises some weird
29:09.2
rules-based international order
29:15.0
You are supporting of it,
29:16.3
supportive of it.
29:17.7
And when it comes to,
29:19.6
technically you're different
29:20.5
but the ICC is also about
29:22.5
rules-based international order,
29:24.1
That you cannot just go
29:25.6
your own citizens.
29:26.6
So, don't you think
29:28.2
an alignment there
29:29.1
whereby you cannot
29:30.6
because that's what
29:32.3
China is pick and choosing,
29:33.7
So, if you want to have
29:34.5
the moral ascendancy,
29:35.8
you want the international
29:36.5
community behind you,
29:38.2
that you're consistently
29:40.8
international order
29:43.6
international humanitarian law,
29:45.4
United Nations Convention
29:46.9
I mean, this is where
29:48.1
a little bit tricky, right?
29:49.2
If the Marcos administration
29:50.9
continues with its
29:51.6
current, you know,
29:55.1
I think there will be
30:00.8
against all of them,
30:02.9
including the Vice President
30:04.5
because she's also
30:06.2
being named there,
30:11.3
of the government
30:11.9
could still change.
30:14.7
as being set in stone.
30:20.0
I mean, let's be honest.
30:20.9
I think it's more like
30:22.9
parang drop on the rock.
30:25.3
What Duterte is doing
30:28.3
the incumbent President.
30:29.7
And you just don't
30:30.5
threaten the incumbent
30:37.1
in a rally against you.
30:39.3
you don't do that.
30:41.5
he is the sitting
30:44.4
if you have anything
30:46.1
against the President,
30:48.8
Do it the legal way.
30:58.1
you know what he said
30:59.3
in his conference
31:01.7
be something there
31:02.5
that we could implode.
31:10.5
to rebellion almost,
31:11.9
Or something worse,
31:19.6
the proxies of China
31:22.1
saan galing yung tapang na yan
31:23.4
to challenge Marcos
31:25.2
Is it because may amo sila
31:26.4
na malakas na sumusuporta
31:28.8
are we already in that situation
31:31.3
the lines are clear?
31:32.4
Or, I don't know,
31:33.2
are we still pretending
31:34.7
everything is normal
31:35.7
factional politics?
31:50.5
Because if you are
31:52.4
Philistine dispute,
31:55.1
our sovereign rights.
32:09.5
The maeso rallies
32:10.4
is supposed to be
32:11.1
their nationwide rallies
32:15.5
pivot to the U.S.
32:24.5
in the South China Sea
32:27.9
island territories
32:29.3
and maritime zones.
32:30.7
It's the only country
32:32.4
that is invading us.
32:34.9
The dispute really
32:35.8
is between the Philippines
32:38.7
it's not the China-U.S. dispute.
32:44.6
because it's our treaty ally.
32:47.6
China on our own.
32:50.2
that's what China wants,
32:51.2
Justice Carpenter.
32:52.2
We want to follow
32:55.3
what the allies want.
32:57.7
we want to solo them.
32:59.2
we don't have a fight.
33:00.2
It's going to be,
33:01.4
it's not a fair fight.
33:02.8
Can you just imagine,
33:08.1
from the South China Sea,
33:11.8
becomes the national boundary.
33:23.8
It's as simple as that.
33:28.8
under international law,
33:30.4
there is no more dispute.
33:36.7
if China will respect
33:38.0
our exclusive economic zone,
33:40.9
the gas in wind bank,
33:41.9
which is within our EEZ,
33:47.6
it's really China's move
33:48.5
to grab what is ours
33:50.8
that's forcing us
33:55.2
our hands is forced.
33:56.5
We are being defensive,
33:59.1
I think the president
33:59.7
was clear about it.
34:00.4
It's really a defensive move.
34:01.8
China doesn't want us
34:03.7
to ask the support
34:06.4
it will be purely
34:07.5
China against the Philippines.
34:09.1
And it's not much.
34:10.4
we want less a day.
34:14.1
may nagsis circulate na,
34:17.9
yung sinabi ko na
34:19.1
ilokano itong Zoom natin
34:21.2
I'll send you another link
34:22.2
because I want to have
34:22.9
a short follow-up
34:25.8
and Kibuloy and all.
34:34.4
ang bilis ng 40 minutes,
34:41.3
it's a picture of
34:42.2
different ASEAN flags.
34:44.4
Yung ibang ASEAN countries
34:50.6
Yung sa taas naman,
34:51.6
they're trying to cover
34:52.5
themselves from umbrella.
34:53.5
Habang yung Pilipinas
34:56.0
we na water cannon.
34:60.0
the idea is that,
35:01.1
the ASEAN is fiddling
35:02.5
while we na water cannon
35:04.9
yung mga ibang bansa
35:06.0
katulad ng Pilipinas
35:08.5
to a certain degree,
35:09.9
I think we can talk
35:10.5
a little bit about that more.
35:12.8
before we close this
35:13.8
and then open another Zoom
35:15.6
shortly to discuss
35:16.5
a little bit more,
35:17.3
should we realistically
35:20.4
hindi natin maasa
35:21.7
ng ASEAN as a whole
35:22.7
to really be on our side?
35:23.8
Kasi I keep on hearing
35:25.7
hindi naman pro-China,
35:26.9
pero dahil anti-America sila,
35:29.6
dun na tayo sa ASEAN.
35:31.6
ASEAN is practically
35:34.1
what other evidence
35:38.2
But not on this one.
35:39.6
let's just be realistic
35:42.4
all those who are not involved,
35:44.6
all those who are not
35:45.6
prejudiced by the
35:51.1
them to support us.
35:52.9
Because they're getting
35:54.8
investments from China.
35:55.9
That's their number one
35:59.6
countries that are
36:01.3
similarly situated
36:07.3
Brunei is too small
36:08.6
to make a difference.
36:10.3
And even the Malaysia
36:11.3
is a bit questionable.
36:12.6
We'll discuss it very shortly.
36:13.6
I'll send you the new link
36:17.3
Because Malaysia,
36:19.7
what they wanted.
36:22.0
They were able to survey
36:24.2
And that's why Anwar said,
36:25.5
we don't have a problem
36:27.3
Because they already
36:30.7
Thank you so much,
36:32.1
I'll get back to you.
36:33.4
Paubos na itong link natin.
36:34.5
I'll send you a link
36:35.8
My apologies for that.
36:36.8
Ang bilis pala ng 40 minutes.
36:38.2
I'll get back to you
36:38.9
because we need the last part
36:40.0
dito sa episode natin
36:41.0
to discuss a little bit more
36:42.9
and then a little bit about
36:44.9
to close off this.
36:47.3
Thank you very much, Justice.
36:51.9
yung account ko na,
36:56.3
yung account ko ng
37:00.4
yung faculty account,
37:02.4
hindi siya gumagana.
37:03.2
So, I'm trying to figure out.
37:12.0
I'll host another one shortly.
37:23.8
Mahal kasi mag-ano eh.
37:25.5
Mag-register ng sariling
37:30.6
Send ko ito kay Justice.
37:33.6
Copy invite link.
37:37.7
And uminit na yung discussion, ha.
37:39.7
Uminit na yung discussion.
37:40.7
Uminit na yung discussion.
38:21.1
Huwag kayong malis
38:22.2
Pag-usapan pa natin ito
38:23.8
Gusto ko rin tanongin
38:29.6
Batao versus Bulljack
38:32.8
Kailangan talaga natin panoor
38:36.5
Matter of national interest yan
38:38.3
Hindi ako makatulog kagabig
38:41.3
Sakaka edit niyan
38:43.0
Kasi inedit ko yung
38:44.9
Ano yung caption niya
38:46.1
Kung ano yung lumalabas sa caption
38:48.7
Alam niyo na yung sinasabi ko
38:51.5
Hindi ko talaga kaya to guys
38:58.8
Nagkalit na sa akin si Marlica
39:01.0
Si Rito Ronald Bato de la Rosa
39:07.6
Hindi ako at si Morales
39:10.5
Magtatanong na ba ako
39:11.8
Na nabayaran ka ni Lisa
39:13.2
How irresponsible
39:16.1
Eh ang ala natin talaga yung si Justice Carpichan
39:20.5
We are trying our best here to come up with the truth
39:23.5
And nothing but the truth
39:25.3
Wala tayong pinapanigan
39:28.7
Pati ako tinitira na
39:34.1
Pakinggan ka namin
39:37.0
Gagamitin mo yung power of the media para siraan ako
39:49.2
Tama naman si sir
39:56.3
Hearing na ito dapat
39:58.0
Magpapahil pa ako ng
39:59.8
Magpapahil pa ako ng
40:02.6
Ito ito Justice Carpichan
40:04.1
Ito yung hearing ni Bato de la Rosa
40:08.0
Si Buljack Marlica
40:11.1
There is no way we can discuss
40:13.2
Philippine politics
40:15.3
That will be the last part of our discussion today Justice
40:20.4
Kasi Justice Carpichan
40:21.5
Alam mo naman ano na tayo eh
40:23.6
Kailangan natin analyze lahat
40:25.0
Kasi there's no way to understand foreign policy ng Philippines
40:27.8
Without understanding itong mga latest
40:30.2
Mga Buljackan na nangyari sa politika natin
40:33.3
So thank you very much again for joining us
40:34.7
Ito na magtitape na tayo
40:36.5
We're back ito sa
40:38.6
Non-commercial account natin
40:40.8
So sorry for the break
40:42.0
Of course habang may break kanina
40:43.6
Pinalikan natin itong
40:45.1
Hearing dyan sa Senado
40:47.5
Kung saan nagre-reklamo si
40:49.3
Si Senator Bato de la Rosa
40:52.8
Itong mga expose daw
40:54.7
Itong expose daw na nangyari sa
40:58.5
Ito Justice Carpichan
41:01.4
I wanna ask about this
41:05.0
In the earlier part of our discussion
41:07.0
We look at the picture in the West Philippine Sea
41:09.7
Anong mga kailangan natin gawin
41:10.9
Anong pwede natin maasaan sa mga kapitbahay natin
41:13.5
Pero ang tanong kasi dito
41:15.1
Sobrang unstable tayo domestically
41:17.4
You need a whole of nation approach
41:19.1
Yun ang term na I keep on hearing right now
41:21.6
From government officials
41:22.9
Which is a good thing
41:23.6
Because that's what we really need
41:24.9
We need a whole of nation approach
41:26.3
But we have a crazy situation
41:28.2
Hindi lang away ng mga Duterte at saka mga Marcoses
41:30.9
Ba't yung mga pro-Duterte people
41:32.9
Ay nag-away ngayon
41:34.9
Ay naaway si Bato de la Rosa
41:36.4
And then more worryingly
41:38.1
May nakikita na tayong mga
41:40.0
Inklings of influence operations
41:43.1
I mean may nakita tayo na
41:45.1
I think ang tawag dyan technically is
41:47.7
Kasing deep fake medyo ginagastusan eh
41:50.4
Yung nakita natin cheap fake
41:52.0
Kung saan sinisimulate si Bongbong Marcos
41:55.4
Na kunyari he's doing something aggressive
41:57.5
Against China etc
41:58.4
So we already have an inkling of
42:00.1
The direction of the wind diba
42:01.7
Kung ganun yung mga alam mo na papunta saan
42:03.5
Can we talk about this?
42:05.4
How worried are you Justice Carpe
42:07.1
About the prospect of destabilization
42:10.0
Let's use the term that they used to use
42:11.4
Against us for 6 years
42:13.0
Do you think there's a destabilization
42:15.8
Ongoing or that could intensify further
42:19.1
And potentially backed by a foreign power
42:23.3
Di umano'y backed up by a foreign power
42:26.7
Well it's very possible
42:29.8
Because these people could be desperate already
42:35.5
These people have the moral scruples
42:39.0
They will go for assassination
42:43.3
Can they pull it off?
42:46.6
The president is well protected
42:50.4
They always give hints
42:52.6
First they demand
42:54.2
The president should step down
42:56.6
And you know if he resigns
42:58.6
You know who will take over
43:01.5
It doesn't take a rocket scientist
43:04.5
To know their direction
43:07.5
If they are cornered
43:09.7
Because they could be sent to the Hague
43:12.3
They just might do something
43:15.3
But I don't think they can pull it off
43:17.4
It will be a desperate move
43:20.2
I don't think they will succeed
43:22.7
I know how well protected
43:25.9
The president is with the PSG
43:29.7
Is solidly behind the commander-in-chief
43:33.3
Indoctrinated with the doctrine of
43:35.4
The commander-in-chief
43:36.8
And their loyalty to the constitution
43:40.9
So I doubt that if
43:43.0
It can be anybody who tries to do something like that
43:44.9
To do any destabilization
43:52.3
If they are cornered
43:53.4
I think a cornered beast
43:55.7
Is sometimes a bit dangerous
44:00.2
You have to always err on the side of caution
44:02.8
We are a heartbeat away
44:05.2
From a change of regime
44:06.5
Not only administration
44:07.7
And totally change of our foreign policy direction
44:10.0
Some people would say
44:11.0
Does the president have people he can rely on?
44:14.8
Because for a long time
44:15.9
Justice Carpenter
44:17.6
BBM doesn't have a bongo
44:19.5
His bongo is Vic Rodriguez
44:20.9
Of course we know what happened
44:22.1
And the people who are now
44:23.7
His chief of staff
44:24.6
These are clerical people
44:28.1
No offense to some of your former colleagues
44:29.9
Or these are people
44:35.2
I think people know who I'm referring to
44:37.4
He doesn't have a bongo
44:38.8
But my understanding is
44:40.3
Someone like Secretary Año
44:41.8
Is emerging as the kind of
44:44.4
The ultimate adult in the room
44:46.4
Someone who's extremely capable
44:48.6
I interviewed him in the past
44:49.8
I'm constantly in touch with people
44:51.4
From National Security Council
44:52.9
What are the concerns of our country
44:54.4
Is that also your reading?
44:57.1
It's the whole system, right?
45:00.1
General Braunemos
45:00.9
But parang sa tingin ko si
45:02.2
Año talaga yung ano ngayon
45:04.2
Siya yung ultimate
45:04.8
Adult in the room
45:07.1
Very strongly pushback siya kay Digong
45:11.1
When he was the LG secretary
45:13.0
He used to work with
45:14.4
When he was stationed there
45:15.6
As an AFP commander
45:19.2
Great faith in our
45:24.4
That they will do
45:25.5
The correct thing
45:37.8
And they had no choice
45:42.3
From the president
45:43.0
From President Duterte
45:47.3
Will put up cell sites
45:51.5
China would be listening
45:52.7
To all our communications
45:57.5
Dutifully followed
45:58.6
The commander-in-chief
46:05.3
Until Duterte left
46:11.3
Are not implementing it
46:16.5
Yung Chinese telecom stuff
46:18.9
They know what to do
46:21.2
These people are intelligent
46:25.1
The purpose of China
46:26.6
What China is doing
46:31.0
Their purpose in life
46:33.6
Philippine territory
46:37.3
And they will not do anything
46:44.8
Duty of a soldier
46:46.9
The basic duty of a soldier
46:48.5
Is to defend the Philippine state
46:50.9
And they will not do anything
46:57.2
Mission of theirs
46:58.4
So I have great faith
46:59.8
In the armed forces
47:00.6
I definitely share that
47:02.2
I think one of the pieces
47:03.1
I'm most proud of
47:04.7
New York Times op-ed
47:05.8
I did back in the day
47:07.0
Not Duterte's personal army
47:10.2
From 2017 onwards
47:13.9
Kung maging private army
47:16.5
Unfortunately about PNP
47:17.7
We can have a separate discussion
47:23.3
Ang tawag ko dyan
47:24.9
I think the main media
47:26.2
And folks like you
47:28.3
All of us together
47:29.0
Plus the military
47:30.1
We really held the line
47:31.1
During that six years
47:31.8
Because I think we were very close
47:33.0
To complete regime change
47:34.8
I think Duterte was just
47:36.5
If only he were a bit more competent
47:38.0
And we were a little bit more
47:40.7
Fortunately we were not
47:41.9
I agree with that
47:44.5
There's gonna be still political
47:45.7
Motslinging among others
47:47.6
And one of the things
47:48.4
We're seeing right now
47:49.1
Is this interesting
47:49.8
Back and forth between
47:53.8
Senator Bato de la Rosa
48:01.5
Hindi media personality yan
48:05.0
Hindi nga vlogger yan
48:09.8
Hindi media personality
48:12.3
Hindi rin vlogger
48:13.2
Wag nyo na ma-insultate
48:14.7
Vlogger na rin ako
48:15.6
Hindi naman kami ganyan
48:21.4
This whole pulveronic
48:24.8
Na meron daw silang
48:28.1
Tapos meron daw ito sa
48:30.2
Meron daw documents about BBM
48:31.9
Which Duterte was referring to
48:34.4
Do you think something is going on there?
48:36.9
Divided din yung mga DDS
48:39.3
Whatever you want to call them
48:40.4
On how to approach
48:41.6
Because this is dangerous
48:42.6
I mean if you're gonna go
48:43.9
There and try to implicate
48:45.0
The president on this
48:46.1
The hammer will come down
48:51.4
If they have any evidence
48:55.7
Brought it out already
48:57.9
I don't think they have anything
49:03.2
Where do you think
49:04.2
The investigation will go
49:06.8
The gentleman's agreement
49:07.8
The whole Marites
49:09.0
Do you think that's something
49:10.5
That could also be
49:11.4
I don't want to use the word
49:13.9
Maybe they're also desperate
49:15.4
Not only on the ICC issue
49:17.0
Because pwede na sila mapindaon dito sa
49:19.1
Well allegations of treason
49:20.9
Of course wala tayong treason law
49:24.7
The gentleman's agreement
49:25.5
Could be very much contrary
49:26.5
To our national interest
49:27.4
So if you look at the resolution
49:28.5
Of the Philippine Congress
49:29.5
It more or less says
49:31.0
It was contrary to our national interest
49:35.0
There's a provision in the anti-graft law
49:37.5
You're liable for anti-graft
49:41.3
Do anything that is not
49:43.9
Injures the government
49:45.3
That causes undue damage
49:47.7
To the government
49:48.3
Because of your inexcusable
49:51.7
Or manifest bad faith
49:55.3
It could fall under that
50:00.7
That's causing undue damage
50:03.3
To the government
50:04.4
Because we will lose our
50:05.9
Part of our EEZ to China
50:08.3
I mean when you agree that
50:09.9
We will not repair
50:12.7
That means that you will lose
50:14.9
We will allow it to sink
50:15.8
We will have to leave the area
50:17.4
Because we will lose our outpost
50:19.4
That's the meaning of that
50:21.3
So he could be held liable for that
50:23.9
Even if he's not a sitting
50:25.3
Government official anymore
50:26.3
What kind of penalties
50:27.4
Are we looking at?
50:28.0
The prescriptive period for that
50:31.2
So it goes beyond their tenure
50:34.0
Punishments are we looking at
50:36.5
If held accountable
50:44.9
To bring it to the other side
50:48.3
The walls are closing in
50:50.9
If you're in that camp
50:52.8
Things are not looking that good for them
50:54.1
That's why I said
50:54.6
Maybe they're desperate
50:57.6
To see what kind of mess
50:58.9
They're going to do
50:59.6
Thank you so much
51:01.9
I think this was a very extensive discussion
51:03.7
I don't want to force
51:05.1
I want to talk more
51:06.7
But I'd rather come back to you later on
51:08.4
Because I'm sure you have a lot
51:09.4
To also deal with
51:11.4
Let's go back to Davao
51:13.3
Do you think our good AFP
51:15.4
Should also step in
51:16.6
And deal with the Kibuloy issue
51:18.6
Because it looks like
51:20.8
They have military army people
51:23.4
I saw some ceremonies
51:25.0
Like the Kibuloy Academy
51:27.3
Helping those who want to join the army
51:29.4
What's the score there?
51:30.4
I'm seeing a lot of stuff there
51:32.0
What happened there?
51:35.7
I haven't verified that
51:40.6
The DOJ should send
51:45.3
To look for Kibuloy
51:47.0
Because you cannot rely on the police there
51:50.4
To what degree is the Kibuloy saga
51:53.5
Important on the potential fall of the House of Duterte?
52:00.7
Kung hindi mahuli-huli si Kibuloy
52:03.7
He's just gonna be a
52:05.2
Easygoing fugitive
52:07.7
What are the prospects for
52:09.1
Even more powerful people being held accountable?
52:12.3
Maybe it's a matter of
52:13.2
Choose your battles
52:14.0
And go for what's more important
52:14.9
Do you get what I'm saying, right?
52:16.9
It's easy for people to be skeptical
52:18.9
Ang itis ni sabi nyo
52:21.1
Malapit na gano'n
52:21.9
Eh tignan nyo nga si Bantag
52:24.6
Going around pa rin
52:25.4
Tapos yung mga videos na
52:26.5
From last year na birthday niya
52:29.3
Which gives the wrong impression
52:30.7
Na this guy is having a good time
52:32.1
Maybe he is, right?
52:33.7
There's also this skepticism
52:35.2
If not cynicism na
52:36.4
This is all noise
52:38.0
At the end of the day
52:38.8
Powerful people get away
52:42.6
Injustice and wrongdoings
52:44.2
Are you confident
52:45.8
That the arc of justice
52:47.3
I mean the history is bending
52:48.4
Towards the arc of justice
52:49.3
Finally at least on this issue
52:50.6
Because there's so much
52:52.4
National interest
52:55.9
Ang dami na nilang kalaban
52:58.1
Nag-away na ngayon
53:09.3
If you have Bantag
53:12.6
Beyond the reach of the law
53:16.5
And if you have Kibuloy
53:17.8
I think that will be a
53:19.3
That will show some incompetence
53:22.8
Parang Tevez lang
53:24.4
Alam ko nahuli lang Tevez so far
53:26.4
But still I mean yeah
53:28.9
Well Tevez is out of the country
53:31.1
But these two are here
53:33.6
You have to find them
53:35.9
If you cannot find them
53:38.6
The police and the NBI
53:44.1
That raises questions
53:45.3
About chain of command's
53:49.2
In that era of GPS
53:50.8
And drones and everything
53:52.1
Hindi mo mahanap yung mga taong
53:53.6
I'm having a hard time
53:54.9
Believing that to be honest
53:57.1
I forgot to ask you
53:58.1
What do you think about
54:01.2
By the Manila Times
54:04.1
Beijing's mouthpiece
54:05.5
Directly attacking Digong
54:11.3
Galit kami ni Ron
54:12.6
At kasi di kami sinama doon
54:13.9
Sinama pa si Gretchen
54:21.6
Ngayon galit na yung
54:25.0
Mouthpiece na daw siya
54:26.0
What's going on there
54:30.7
I mean what's going on here
54:36.5
In what they're doing
54:41.0
On the other side
54:43.3
A lot of people now
54:45.4
The political parties
54:47.6
And joining the party
54:51.5
So baka ganyan din yan
54:53.1
So we have to look and see
55:03.7
Something positive
55:05.0
I'm just being so
55:06.7
Pinipilit ko na lang
55:07.8
Maging optimistic
55:08.5
About our country
55:09.5
Pero diba Justice Carver
55:10.9
Kung hindi mo mauli si Banda
55:14.3
It's hard to get people
55:15.4
Excited about justice
55:16.8
When it comes to someone
55:19.9
The president has to show some teeth
55:22.9
Kaya nga tawag sa kanya
55:30.9
Dapat pakita siya ng ano
55:36.1
They can find this too
55:40.6
They know where they are
55:44.4
If they could not be
55:48.2
May 3 in 1 package
55:54.6
Dahil ilokahan nung
55:57.2
I 3 in 1 na natin
55:58.7
Isang araw na natin
56:02.1
Para kompleto yung
56:04.8
Kung cheap fake yung kabila
56:10.8
Is there anything else
56:12.2
Dun sa mga kapabayan natin
56:13.5
Thank you so much
56:16.0
Which is not discussed
56:21.2
Ng tama yung gobyerno
56:22.3
Pero in Scarborough
56:25.2
Sequential lawfare
56:27.2
And then potentially
56:29.0
With directly challenging
56:31.7
And semi-occupation
56:34.1
Kasi nakatinggal lang tayo
56:41.2
We should do something
56:42.8
Thank you very much
56:45.7
Hopefully next time
56:46.6
Hindi na ito yung mga
56:48.6
Yung gagawin natin
56:49.7
Gagana yung UP faculty natin
56:51.3
Otherwise kailangan ko na
56:53.5
Thank you very much
56:55.6
More power to you
56:56.7
And talk to you soon
56:57.7
Hopefully we can arrange
56:59.2
Kasi ang init lang ngayon
57:01.3
Medyo kung hindi na mainit
57:02.2
Let's arrange in person
57:03.2
Naman mag-upo tayo
57:04.7
Lots lots to discuss
57:06.5
Thank you so much sir
57:09.4
And thank you to our viewers
57:13.9
Pwede na kayo lumipat
57:15.0
Sa kabilang channel
57:19.1
Dito na naman yung
57:24.6
Thank you so much
57:25.3
Maraming salamat again
57:26.2
Dito sa mga nanood sa atin
57:32.2
Hindi gumagana yung
57:33.5
UP faculty account ko
57:36.3
What's going on there
57:38.0
Itong mga cheap account
57:42.1
Naisamahin sa atin
57:43.0
So thanks for your
57:43.7
Patience and love
57:44.6
Patience and love
57:45.7
And thanks also dun sa mga
57:47.5
Bakit hindi nyo pinansin
57:50.9
Pinag-irapan ko yan
57:52.1
Na in-edit-edit ko
57:53.5
Pero mali-mali pa rin
57:55.1
Yung ibang auto-caption
57:56.6
Tuloy lumalabas yung
58:04.3
Hindi makuha ng auto-caption
58:35.5
Media personality
58:37.1
Parang media personality yan
58:38.8
Nothing but the truth
58:40.2
Nothing but the truth
58:43.9
Pati ako tinitira na
58:51.2
Pakinggan ka namin
58:53.7
Gagamitin mo yung power
59:03.3
Tama naman si sir eh
59:10.2
Ayos yung part na yan
59:12.3
Itong hearing na ito dapat
59:13.6
Magpapile pa ako ng
59:16.9
Magpapile pa ako ng
59:19.4
Okay medyo hindi na naman alam
59:20.7
Pag-irip ito sa plenary
59:25.0
Bago ito ma-assign sa committee ko
59:28.0
Para gandak ng hearing
59:29.7
Pag hindi ko ginawa yan
59:31.1
Ginamit ko yung aking
59:33.1
Oversight function
59:37.0
Kasi ang ingay na nila eh
59:38.5
Natutulog daw ako
59:39.4
Wala akong ginagawa
59:43.3
Bakasyon na senado
59:45.2
Paano ako makapag-action
59:45.9
Na bakasyon na senado
59:47.0
Ang hirap niyo mahalika
59:50.0
Guys kung mahal mo ang Pilipinas
59:53.1
Huwag mo idama yung
59:55.0
Tao dito na nagtatrabaho
60:07.2
Feeling ko ang susabihin na
60:10.1
Feeling ko hindi niyo masabi
60:11.7
On that note guys
60:12.5
Thank you very much
60:13.8
I hope na enjoy niya
60:14.8
Itong discussion natin
60:16.2
Pinag-usapan natin
60:23.6
Ganun po yung style natin
60:27.7
Please don't compare me
60:29.3
To other vloggers
60:30.3
Talagang wala tayong comparison
60:31.9
We do it totally differently
60:35.9
Kamusta kayo dyan
60:37.8
Enjoy niyo yung gabi na yan
60:39.0
At lumipat na kayo
60:39.8
Sa kabilang channel
60:41.0
Thank you very much
60:41.6
God bless and talk to you soon
